What Folktales Reveal about Europe’s Historical Moral Systems
by Elisa Flori
What can stories told generations ago reveal about the values and social norms that shaped European societies?
Passed down across generations, folktales preserve ideas about right and wrong, authority and injustice, collective behaviour and personal virtues. They therefore offer a unique window into the moral worlds of past societies.
As part of the NET-ROL project, researchers analysed more than 13,000 historical folktales from 37 European countries to reconstruct historical moral systems: interconnected configurations of values and social norms embedded in traditional narratives. The research team engaged in this work first extrapolated historical values and social norms from each of the collected folktales, making use of artificial intelligence trained for the scope. Subsequently, different values were allowed to interconnect in correlation networks that were computed for each single country over all folktales collected for the specific folklore tradition. This analysis presents the perspective that emerges: the same set of values interconnects differently across different European countries. We observe differences in such moral systems.
A shared European moral core
In the aggregate European moral system, one particularly striking finding is the central position of third-party punishment: the willingness to respond to unfair behaviour experienced by someone else. Rather than pursuing personal revenge, it involves reacting to injustice on behalf of others and potentially delegating the pursuit of justice to a third party. Its centrality suggests that accountability and the protection of others occupy an important place in the moral traditions preserved by European folktales. Such values are supportive of the Rule of Law.
Attention to detail also occupies a central position, suggesting that precision, care and thoroughness have long been regarded as important virtues within European moral culture.
Values that repeatedly travel together
Some relationships between values appear in nearly all 37 country-specific moral systems. Reasonable risk-taking is closely connected with starting again after failure and pursuing a higher social position, forming a recurring configuration centred on ambition, resilience and personal agency. Honesty, hard work and patience also tend to be closely interconnected.
Common roots, different configurations
Despite these commonalities, the position of specific values varies across countries. Generalized trust is particularly central in Finland, whereas loyalty towards family members and other close-knit groups plays a stronger bridging role in Serbia, Albania, Croatia and Slovenia.
Other distinctive configurations also emerge. In Italy, nepotism connects otherwise separate parts of the moral system. Whistleblowing occupies an unusually prominent bridging position in Malta and Moldova, while third-party punishment stands out in Sweden.
Our team is looking forward to further develop these initial findings into further insights.